Key takeaways
- A digital loyalty card lives in a phone's wallet or on a web page, and customers add it in seconds with nothing to download.
- An app earns its cost when customers have reasons to open it besides the stamp, such as ordering ahead or offers that change often.
- The cost app owners forget to plan for is getting customers into the app in the first place.
- A QR code with a deferred deep link takes a new customer from the counter straight to their loyalty card, so the visit that convinced them to install still counts.
A café owner decides it's time for a loyalty program and starts asking around. One vendor demos a stamp card that lives in Apple Wallet. Another pitches a branded mobile loyalty app. The owner goes with whichever demo looked better, and a choice that will shape the program for years gets made in an afternoon.
That choice deserves more thought. This post walks through both options in plain terms and helps you work out which one fits your business, including a cost that catches plenty of app owners off guard.
The two options in plain terms
A digital loyalty card is a stamp card that sits on the customer's phone without an app of its own. Usually it's a pass in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, or a card on a web page. The customer adds it once, often by scanning a QR code, and each visit updates the stamps.
The other option is your own app, with the loyalty card as one screen inside it. Customers download it and create an account, then collect points or stamps there. Everything else your business offers on a phone can live in the same app, from ordering to their past purchases.
When a digital card is enough
A card fits a business where the loyalty program is the whole relationship with the customer. That usually means a handful of locations at most and a single reward, like a free coffee after five, with no ordering ahead.
Setup is quick, and customers add the card in a few seconds. Every step between a customer and their first stamp loses some people, and a card has very few steps.
You give up room to grow. A card holds stamps and not much else. You can't take orders through it, and your ways of reaching customers with something new are limited.
When an app pays off
An app earns its cost when customers have reasons to open it besides the stamp. Ordering ahead is the biggest one, and table ordering works the same way, as the restaurant guide shows. Once a customer orders their usual from the app, they open it several times a week, and each open is a chance to show them something.
Offers that change often fit an app better too. You can put a new one in front of customers the day it's ready, and push messages let you tell a regular about the new seasonal drink. Groups with several locations or brands get one place for all of it, with the loyalty balance following the customer from store to store.
Over time the app builds a record of what each customer orders. That history lets you shape offers around the person, which a stamp card has no way to do.
The cost owners forget to plan for
Building and maintaining an app has a bill everyone expects. Getting customers into the app has one too, and it's the one owners forget.
Picture the moment at the counter. A customer hears about the app, scans a code, and lands on the App Store or Google Play page. They wait for the download, open the app, and find a sign-up form with no mention of the coffee they just bought. Many give up at the form. Those who finish start with an empty card, and the visit that sold them on the app is gone.
How a QR code and a deep link close the gap
The scan at the counter needs to lead straight into the loyalty card, including for someone who doesn't have the app yet. Deferred deep linking handles that. The link behind the QR code remembers where it's meant to go while the customer installs, then opens the app on their loyalty card the first time they launch it, with today's visit ready to be counted. Your app awards the stamp, and the link gets the customer to the right screen with the details it needs.
The download is still an extra step compared with a card, and the handoff works best when the customer installs and opens the app right there at the counter. What changes is that the customer lands on the stamp they came for, and the visit that got them interested still counts. With attribution on the link, you can also see how many installs each counter brings in.
The digital punch card guide walks through that setup step by step, and the QR code marketing guide covers where to place codes in a shop.
A quick way to decide
Answer these about your business:
- Do customers order ahead, or would they if they could?
- Do you run more than a handful of locations, or more than one brand?
- Do your offers change more than once a month?
- Do you already have an app, or a team that can build and maintain one?
Four noes point to a digital loyalty card. It will serve you well and cost less. Two or more yeses make the case for an app, as long as you plan for the moment customers install it. With a single yes, start with a card and come back to the question when that answer gets stronger.
If the app is the right call, Ulinkly handles the link between your counter and your app. It's free for up to 10,000 monthly active users per project, with unlimited links and a basic QR code for each one. Deferred deep linking and install attribution, the parts that carry the stamp through the install, come with the Starter plan at $9 a month.
Frequently asked questions
What is a digital loyalty card?
A digital loyalty card is a stamp or points card that lives on a customer's phone without a dedicated app. It's usually a pass in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, or a card on a web page. Customers add it by scanning a QR code, collect a stamp on each visit, and get a reward after a set number of stamps.
Do I need an app for a loyalty program?
No. A digital loyalty card works well when loyalty is the main relationship you have with customers, such as a few locations with a single reward and no ordering. An app makes sense when customers have other reasons to open it, like ordering ahead or offers that change often.
Is a wallet loyalty card or a loyalty app better?
It depends on what else you want customers doing on their phone. A wallet card is quicker to set up and easier for customers to add. An app can handle ordering, changing offers, and messages, and it costs more to build and to get customers into. Count how many reasons customers have to open the app besides the stamp, and decide from there.
How do you get customers to download a loyalty app?
Put a QR code where customers already have their phone out, such as the counter or the receipt, with a clear reason to scan, like collecting today's stamp. Use a deferred deep link behind the code so the app opens on their loyalty card after the install, with the visit ready to be counted. Ask them to open the app before they leave, which is when the handoff is most reliable.
How much does each option cost?
Digital loyalty card platforms usually charge a monthly subscription. An app costs more to build and maintain, plus whatever it takes to get customers to install it. For that install step, Ulinkly's deferred deep linking and attribution start at $9 a month, and links and basic QR codes are free for up to 10,000 monthly active users per project.
Get customers from your counter into your app
If an app is the right fit for your business, Ulinkly makes sure a scan at the counter lands on the loyalty card, even for a first-time install. Create a free Ulinkly account to set up your first link.
